The short answer depends less on which model is “better” and more on what kind of cost structure your work actually has. Astra and Sol share a 1,050,000-token context window, 128K max output, and the same tool surface. They differ in price by a factor of four on input and output, and they differ in where that premium buys you something measurable. This guide maps the decision to task types, token economics, and the benchmarks where the gap is largest.

The price surface, stated plainly

Astra runs at $8.00 per million input tokens and $40.00 per million output tokens. Sol runs at $2.00 and $10.00. Cached input tells the same story: $0.40 on Astra versus $0.10 on Sol. Above 272K input tokens, both step up — Astra to $16 input and $60 output, Sol to $4 and $15 — so the long-context penalty is proportionally identical, just at different absolute levels.

Astra received a 20% cut relative to GPT-6 Astra, while Sol held the GPT-6.1 Sol rate card unchanged. That asymmetry is the first clue about positioning: Astra is being made cheaper to defend a frontier slot; Sol is already cheap enough that it does not need one.

Where Sol is genuinely close enough

On FrontierCode 2.0, Sol finishes within 0.5 percentage points of Astra at roughly one-fifth the per-task cost. Bito’s independent coding-agent sessions at high effort tell a compatible story: Astra scored 77.5% overall at $8.19 per hard session, while Sol scored 76.5% at $2.22 — a one-point quality gap for about a quarter of the spend.

For high-volume code review, routine refactors, retrieval, classification, and multi-step agent tasks that do not require frontier reasoning, the marginal value of Astra is hard to justify on the rate card alone. OpenAI leans into this openly: Sol is framed as the efficient model for everyday work, and the company notes many internal staff default to it.

Where Astra earns its premium

The gap widens on tasks that combine long-horizon planning with expensive failure. On Agents’ Last Exam v1.1 — sustained reasoning, planning, and tool use across hard professional workflows — Astra scores 78.3%, 5.2 points above GPT-6 Astra, at **$2.89 per task**. Claude Fable 5.2 costs $60.05 to complete the same evaluation task. Astra also leads AA-3D at 1318 Elo (Fable 5.2: 1271; Sol: 1259) and AA-Robotics at 79 (Sol: 78; Fable: 75).

These are not benchmarks that flatter a cheaper model. If your workload involves spatial reasoning, scientific research pipelines, or agent runs lasting hours where a silent failure is costly, the premium has a defensible basis — not because the per-token price is low, but because a stalled loop costs more than the token bill.

The decision rule that actually holds

A useful heuristic: run Sol as the default, escalate to Astra per task type. Sol handles the bulk of coding, writing, classification, and routine agent work at a quarter of the input cost and a quarter of the output cost. Astra earns the call-up when the task is long, multi-step, and expensive to get wrong.

There is a caveat worth naming. Early testers reported Astra sometimes stops early on end-to-end builds and loops over extended sessions. Sol has its own regression — Artificial Analysis found a 3-point drop on its Coding Agent Index relative to GPT-6.1 Sol, driven by a 14-point decline on SWE-Atlas-QnA-AA, where Sol more often omits key facts. Neither model is a clean drop-in upgrade on every axis. Benchmark your own distribution before committing to the rate-card difference.

Bottom line

Choose Sol as default if your work is high-volume, well-scoped, and tolerant of occasional brevity. Choose Astra if the task is long-horizon, failure is expensive, and the work touches 3D, science, or agent execution where Astra’s independent edge is measurable. For most teams the right architecture is not “Astra or Sol” — it is Sol everywhere, with a narrow, documented escalation path to Astra.